It's a bike! It's a train! It's a... car?
Download MP3Mack Male:
It's a bike! It's a train! It's a... car? This week the province announced its bike lane legislation, which would also expand provincial oversight of LRT projects.
Stephanie Swensrude:
Plus, city administration will convene a randomized panel to consult on the City Plan, and city council is set to revisit substantial completion.
Mack:
Hi, I'm Mack.
Stephanie:
I'm Stephanie.
Mack:
And we're...
Both:
Speaking Municipally.
Mack:
Welcome back to Speaking Municipally, episode 381. It's been a crazy week, I feel like, Stephanie. So much happening.
Stephanie:
Indeed.
Mack:
You know, we're getting close to Black Friday and Thanksgiving down in the United States and what, almost a month to Christmas. And it just feels like things aren't slowing down. The Edmonton Elks won the Grey Cup on the weekend. Amazing.
Stephanie:
No. Woo! Let's go.
Mack:
And then they had a celebration at the EXPO Centre and not a parade, which we can talk about more. Why isn't there a parade? Crazy stuff happening in the world. GTA 6 has taken over. I understand our mayor, who we know is a big gamer, is, uh, excited about this as well. Long-awaited game. Anthropic had its IPO, trillions of dollars floating around the world. It's a crazy time, Stephanie. And then there's a whole bunch of stuff happening locally as well. It's like the province didn't want to be left out. And so they finally got their bike lane legislation, which we knew was coming for a long time. Um, public now. They're, they're talking about that. It's not in — it's not law yet, of course, but we're gonna talk more about that. The other thing that happened this week is you and I had the opportunity to record our LRT takes. I think so.
Stephanie:
Yes, probably the biggest news of the week is that, uh, we were on LRT Takes and it was so fun. And right away mine got posted. It was very much a jump scare when I opened up Instagram and I was like, my God, it's me. And it was, and it's so good. Guys, if you go look at it, don't, don't, you don't need to look at the comments. The comments are pretty braindead. So
Mack:
Or feel free to chime in and support Stephanie in the comments. Her take is an excellent one. We'll link it in the show —
Stephanie:
Mm-hmm. Thank you.
Mack:
notes. We learned a little bit more. You obviously interviewed Adam on the show here a few episodes ago, but we got to learn a little bit more about how it works doing it firsthand. And I think you and I were both like, my God, that was so fast. So fast. So we might elaborate on some of our takes here in an upcoming episode and actually a little bit in this episode. But for now we'll put it in the show notes as well, so you can go and check out Stephanie's take. We're gonna get into that bike lane stuff, but first let's, uh, let's take care of this ad for you.
Stephanie:
This episode is brought to you by Park Power, your friendly local utilities provider and the title sponsor of Taproot's Regional Roundup. If winter bills are leaving you cold, bundle up with Park Power. Your friendly local utilities provider makes it easy to sign up for electricity, natural gas and internet, and bundling two or three of those together saves you money. It's easy to switch to Park Power, and there are no exit fees if you leave. Learn how much you could save at parkpower.ca. That's parkpower.ca.
Mack:
Okay. Today the government of Alberta released Safe and Sensible Roads. This is what it's calling its sort of omnibus Bill 43, I think it is, all about transit, bike lanes, safety, kinda, depending on your point of view. Stephanie, give us the Coles Notes. What is the province proposing with this new legislation?
Stephanie:
Yes, it's all about making sure our roads stay safe. So what is the first priority that the province touches on? Is it speeding? Is it the size of trucks where short people like me can even be seen under the hood? No, it's taking away bike lanes. Um, so the very first thing in the press release talks about, “Alberta's government is committed to working with municipalities to ensure bike lanes are safely planned and fit within the broader transportation network. Proposed changes would establish clear rules for bike lanes that reduce road capacity for motor vehicles and allow for the removal of existing bike lanes that have reduced road capacity for motor vehicles. The changes would help ensure municipalities consider how bike lanes affect traffic flow, commuters, emergency services, and the movement of goods. The province looks forward to working with municipal partners to build safe, well-connected transportation networks that serve local communities while keeping Alberta moving.”
Mack:
So more infantilization of the municipalities. Like, of course, they didn't consider the impact of the projects that they undertook. And I think I saw in some reporting about this, Minister Dreeshen basically suggesting that the removal of the bike lanes that this legislation would allow for. Yeah, the city will have to pay for that too. Which —
Stephanie:
Yep. Yes.
Mack:
absurd. Okay. We know obviously, like I mentioned, knew this was coming. I think it's been an open secret that the city and council were expecting some provincial rules around bike lanes. Obviously, we've talked on the show many times about Minister Dreeshen and others who have been opposed to bike lanes throughout the city. The province has also launched this online feedback site, and they've had thousands of people submit, you know, feedback, opinions about, uh, bike lanes, both in Edmonton and Calgary, but elsewhere as well. We heard from the mayor this afternoon really quickly in response to this announcement from the province and you are at City Hall. Viewers can see you're in your office there. And so you were down at the presser, right? What did what did Mayor Knack have to say in response?
Stephanie:
Yes, this was like 10, 15 minutes ago. Um, he was salty and sarcastic, probably the most salty I've ever seen him. Really quick sidebar. When he was still running for mayor, I remember going into his campaign office and he had all these like little drawings on the walls from little kids that he went and visited, and one of them said, “Andrew Knack does not get mad,” spelled wrong from like a little kid. And I took a picture of it at the time because I thought it was so cute. But I learned today that Andrew Knack does get mad. He comes in and they — he has these, um, posters or, like, like banners on the wall that's like, “The office of Mayor Andrew Knack”, you know, kind of his official stuff. And he says to all the reporters, he's like, “Do we even need these anymore? It should just say, like, we don't have mayors anymore. It should just say office of Premier Danielle Smith or office of, um, Devin Dreeshen or Dan Williams.” And we were all like, “Oh.” So, yeah, he is salty, he is sassy, he is sarcastic. Uh yeah, he of course just he is obviously not cool with this decision being made. And he later on he was talking a lot about how the province should just focus on the issues over which they have jurisdiction. And he said this.
Andrew Knack:
And I mean, the province, I mean, I'm glad to know that the health-care system is working perfectly right now, because apparently they, they don't have to do anything more there. It's — I think it's perfect now, right? Nobody's dying in our waiting rooms anymore. Because if that was the case, I would expect the province to actually deal with an issue like that. It's great to know that our education system — I think, I think all our rooms are not overcrowded anymore. We've got plenty of schools for everyone. Nobody has to be bused an hour away. Except actually, I think that's still what's happening day in and day out. And they cannot spend their time focusing on the things that are in fact their jurisdiction, that impact the livelihoods of the people that they serve. They clearly don't care about the livelihoods of the people that they serve.
Mack:
You're right. Salty. I love it. A little bit of passion from the mayor. Obviously this is not the first time he's had the opportunity to do this. There was the infill directive and other things as well that are probably all, you know, building up to make him feel a little bit more frustrated with the province than he otherwise would be. I mentioned earlier that the province says, we're gonna have to pay for this if we — if they want us to remove the bike lanes, the city has to pay for it. Where's the logic in that? But anyway, I understand the mayor also addressed that during the press conference.
Stephanie:
Yeah, he said the administration has done some preliminary studies and that it would cost about $150 million to remove the targeted bike lanes. And, uh, that in the proposed 2027–2030 capital budget, that $150 mil is more than administration is proposing to spend on like widening arterial roads or other, you know, uh projects to expand road capacity. So... And then, and then Andrew Knack says, “Well, we're not — we don't want to raise taxes more and increase the capital budget. So if we're taking out those bike lanes, we're gonna have to take money from something else. So maybe we won't widen the roads to take out the bike lanes,” like, um, kind of doing a little bit of a trade-off there, he was saying.
Mack:
Interesting. Maybe that's what they need to do in this situation, right? The province kind of wants to have its cake and eat it too. Like they would be complaining about the city of Edmonton if they raised property taxes significantly. And you know, if council went and approved a a large increase, they would be complaining about that. They also complain about the bike lanes and the projects that Edmonton has decided are in its best interest and are within its jurisdiction to build, right? Like it's kind of insane to me that again, here we are again. Just what, a month after the last time talking about the province basically coming in and telling the city you can't do something that very clearly they are allowed to do. Very frustrating. Did anything else stand out to you uh from the press conference, from from the mayor's remarks?
Stephanie:
So he mentioned that at the conference, Dreeshen put out a list of the top 10 — top 10 most hated bike lanes in Alberta. Number five will shock you. Um, and nine of them are in Edmonton. There's Hermitage Road, which — sidebar — everyone agrees, everyone hates it. Maybe we can talk about that another time. It's a — it is a bad one. No one likes it. Not cyclists, drivers, no one. Victoria Park Road, so that's like going up into downtown into, like, the Wîhkwêntôwin area, 141st Street, 132nd Street, 103rd Street. So that would be downtown on, on the, uh, network. Yeah.
Mack:
On the west side of 103rd, yep.
Stephanie:
96th Street, 100th Street, which I believe would be the section just north of Whyte Avenue, like in the Strathcona area. A very new, well, part of it's a very new bike lane. 50th Street, which would I think be the one that got a bunch of issues this summer in Capilano.
Mack:
It's the one Coun. Salvador was uh raising the discussion about loss —
Stephanie:
I believe so.
Mack:
of that one that was in the news about loss of parking, right?
Stephanie:
Yeah. And then 100th Avenue. So a lot of the — yeah, the
Mack:
100th Avenue, really.
Stephanie:
ones in the downtown grid, Knack was saying, have been around for 10 years and were asked for by Edmonton's biggest company that's ever come out of here, I think, Stantec, because all of these engineers and and stuff were like, “We want a cheap and active and fun way to get to work. Build us a bike network so we can get to the new Stantec Tower.” So Stantec worked with the city and came up with it. So it's not just like these — it's not just the politicians that are asking for this. The OG bike lane network in downtown was actually asked for by the people going to work downtown, you know?
Mack:
Against my better judgment, I went today and read Rick Bell's latest column, which is about this coming legislation. The man does not understand that a paragraph can be more than one sentence. Oh, it's so frustrating to read. But he's wrong, as always, to say that the bike lanes are not busy. I am on that downtown bike lane network, both 102nd Avenue and 100th Avenue, every day of the week. And even now in the dark, when it's getting cold, it is busy. There are lots of bikes. There are still lots of cyclists that use that every day. Not just people going to Stantec, but all kinds of commuters going back and forth, obviously, uh from the west and into downtown. So uh it was, you know, how it came about is one thing. The fact that it is now actively being used and having a positive impact on our broader transportation network downtown is another. And as we were talking about on the show, you know, recently in the context of budget, we can build new bike lanes, call them active pathways, and they can be part of other projects that are happening throughout the city. But things like the downtown bike grid, that needs dedicated funding. That needs intentionality to be able to build something like that. Right. And the fact that we have that is amazing, I think, for, for our downtown, the people that live and work in the two most densely populated parts of our city. It would be such a, such a shame if they have to get ripped up at great expense to Edmonton taxpayers simply because Minister Dreeshen and uh Danielle Smith do not like bike lanes.
Stephanie:
And it just also makes me think like, 100th Avenue doesn't take away a travel lane, does it? Like, it — there's still two lanes of driving plus turning lanes and everything. And that makes me think of um, you know, for example, 83rd Avenue, kind of the South Side equivalent. The 83rd Avenue definitely takes away travel lanes. It has converted it to a one-lane road. And I'm like, uh what about that one? See, it's just — it's obviously no thought was put into this and there's no rhyme or reason for this decision.
Mack:
Yeah, and even if it doesn't take away a drive lane, it might take away a bit of parking. But we have to always remember too that these things are, are additive. They contribute. They make it safer for pedestrians and everybody at some point in their journey, even if they're driving a car, at some point you're a pedestrian, right? The one-way traffic that happens is better for pedestrians. You're not having to like look around, see who's coming the other way. Turning left might be turning across into you. Drivers have to be more cautious when it's — the road doesn't feel like a speedway, it's harder to treat it like one. And that's just safer for everybody involved. So you know, there's little trade-offs in terms of maybe a little bit of loss parking, but like what we gain in exchange for that, to contribute positively to our overall transportation network is just so critical and it's so overlooked by the folks who want to make the decision like this, like what the province is proposing. Well, it's not the law yet, so I guess we'll see how this comes out. It's kind of like the infill one where it's like, this is to come. This is an expense the city might have to incur at some point. Uh I mentioned this legislation, though, is a bit of an omnibus thing, and there's other pieces to it. Uh one that's potentially positive, I think, is that this will now allow the city to bring in rules for private e-scooters and micromobility devices. So currently right now, you're really not supposed to ride your own scooter in the city. You're really only allowed to use Lime or, or Uber or one of those ones. But now this legislation would allow the city to create regulations for private ones, which is good because more options for transportation is kind of what we're talking about. Uh there's another piece to this legislation that you've been looking at, Stephanie though, which is around transit or rail, right? So what are the — what is the province suggesting?
Stephanie:
Yeah, you know, I wasn't expecting that. This was not on my bingo card. Um, so in this omnibus it says amendments to the Urban Rail Transit Act would expand provincial oversight, support better coordination with municipalities on LRT infrastructure, including planning, design, project delivery, et cetera, et cetera. The changes would ensure municipal LRT development aligns with provincial transportation and economic priorities and the Passenger Rail Master Plan, including advancing a high-speed rail connection between downtown Calgary and downtown Edmonton. Now, this could be completely innocuous. It could. It could just be like, hey, just make sure when you do the, you know, south Capital extension, it's a good place that we can connect the high-speed rail. It could also mean potentially, I mean I don't wanna like fearmonger, but I mean what if they come for like actual LRT projects in the centre of our city next?
Mack:
It's innocuous potentially, but also just completely unnecessary. Like we cannot build LRT in this city without the province coming to the table. They're a big funder of any LRT project that has been built in Edmonton or Calgary. They already effectively have a way to say no. I don't understand what this gives them that they don't already have. You know what I mean?
Stephanie:
Yeah, like especially a year or two years ago, if I — if this was announced, I'd be like, there's no way that they're gonna go into Strathearn and change the LRT alignment. There's no way that they're gonna go into mid-construction into Glenora and remove the stop from there. But now two years later, I don't know, maybe my tinfoil hat's on. The other thing, though, is that there is a little — there's, there's four little words in this. Passenger safety-related infrastructure. And I'm wondering if this could even be uh crossing arms on the LRT. You know what I mean? Okay, maybe I don't know. Again, I'm just being a little bit tinfoil hat here, but yeah, you're right. It's just like so weird, so unnecessary. And, um, I don't — I'll, I'll be keeping my little eyes on this one because I don't really know what it means.
Mack:
Expand provincial oversight and support better coordination. It's like, I just feel like you could, if you wanted to coordinate better, you could do that without new legislation, without changing the rules, you know?
Stephanie:
Yeah, exactly.
Mack:
And from a project oversight point of view, like I said, we're not building it without the funding from the province. And so you effectively already have, you know, a gate and an opportunity to provide some input on what that might look like. So, yeah, I — and I also think the last part of this little bit of text that you read for us around the Passenger Rail Master Plan and this proposed high-speed rail connection between downtown Calgary, downtown Edmonton, like this legislation is also not required for that to happen. You know what I mean? Like that's also I feel like a little bit of misdirection um in this legislation. So maybe it seems innocuous at the moment, but it does beg the question why they feel this is so important to be um pushing forward.
Stephanie:
Yeah, totally.
Mack:
Okay, well, this is really new. We're just getting a fresh look at this today as we're recording on Thursday, Nov. 19. So I'm sure we'll dig into this more and we'll learn more. But I know you've been starting to already read through, you know, some of what's proposed here. A few things stood out to you?
Stephanie:
Yeah, so, um, this — I'm not sure if this is a completely new thing, but the, the proposed legislation says a municipality must submit to the minister an urban rail transit network plan that contains this information: the location and alignment of it, uh all of the stops, the type of vehicle, and all related infrastructure. And then the minister has the right to approve it or force it to change certain things. One of the other things in this, in this change is the minister may at any time direct a municipality to make a change respecting the planning, design, project delivery, asset management, or passenger safety-related infrastructure in any existing or proposed urban rail transit lines. So to me, that means the minister gets to give the check mark to LRT and um can also change LRT existing or proposed plans.
Mack:
Yeah, that first document, I'm not sure, like you said, if that's entirely brand new. Obviously, cities are required to submit municipal development plans and transit and transportation are part of those, but that does sound like a more specific thing. Um, you know, the second thing you mentioned, I was, I was thinking that perhaps this legislation has something to do with transit and the city taking back over operations. But what you described there really isn't about operations. It's really it's not about operations, about the design and construction of the line and sort of more the physical stuff rather than the operational stuff. So I guess that's not it. Something else we'll have to dig into a little bit further in the in the days ahead. Okay, well this isn't law yet. Do we know when that's expected?
Stephanie:
Yeah, so if it's passed, the government expects that the legislation would become official, take effect in April, with regulations also scheduled to come in the spring.
Mack:
So as soon as we're done dealing with infill, we'll turn our vast amounts of attention and resources to deal with bike lanes.
Stephanie:
And you know what else? All the bike lanes are gonna go away, and then you know what else is gonna go away? The scrambles! It's the worst summer ever.
Mack:
We can't have anything nice.
Stephanie:
I know.
Mack:
Okay, well, let's switch gears here a little bit. And we want to talk about city plans. So, like I mentioned, cities have to submit municipal development plans. Ours is called The City Plan. And we've brought it up many times over the years because it's the checkpoints that are defined for how our city is growing. It's the guidance for the way that we want the city to grow. And uh both of those things are progressing rapidly and potentially to the point where we need to consider some changes. So I understand the mayor has brought forward a motion to do something about that.
Stephanie:
Yeah, so uh stepping back a little bit, the City Plan instead of having okay, when in in 2025 we want to reach this metric in 2030 this metric, 2035, etc. Instead of doing that, they scale it by population growth because that is, you know, a much more useful metric to, to do by. We very rapidly reached the 1.25 million people population marker. And a municipality's municipal development plan really guides a lot. It guides the transportation network, including bike lanes. It also guides the zoning bylaw.
Mack:
Like are we gonna grow up or out? How are we gonna move around? Where are we gonna put things? When the population grows, where are those people gonna live? Where are they gonna work? Where are they gonna play? All that stuff at a really high level at least is defined in City Plan.
Stephanie:
Yeah, exactly. So that's why sometimes you'll hear in rezonings, like let's say it's just like a, a, uh, lot on the corner of your block, and you might be like, why are they refer— what is the City Plan? Well, the City Plan directs growth along nodes and corridors, and 82nd Avenue is technically a primary corridor. So that's why we should direct growth. Like, I don't know, it's one of these big policy documents that really does affect — like, it filters down and it affects things. So, anyways, every time we — they reach a population milestone, they want to do a little rejig, make sure everything's still working. So Mayor Andrew Knack moved this motion that administration establish a Community Panel on Growth Management and Cost of Living to hear from Edmontonians, including current homeowners and non-homeowners, on challenges and opportunities related to growth management, cost of living, increasing pressures on Edmonton property taxes and infill, and report back to city council with preliminary recommendations at an Urban Planning Committee meeting next September. The community panel should consider, but is not limited to the following: a review of built form regulations for new homes in both redeveloping and developing neighbourhoods, a review of financial performance for redeveloping and developing neighbourhoods, a review of the mass transit strategy, and a review of GHG emissions and climate budget.
Mack:
Okay, well, that's a big, long list of things for a group of Edmontonians to have to deal with. Don't we already have a way to get input on this? Like we have the Edmonton Insight Community. I just filled out a survey the other day. We regularly ask people across the city for input. It is a large, I don't know how representative, but relatively representative community. Why not just use something like that?
Stephanie:
Yeah, so um Knack proposed this. It's kind of based on the citizen panel on climate change, which was something that happened in like the early 2010s. Um, it convened like climate change activists, climate change deniers, and everyone in between, I think, for better or for worse, to talk about climate change and then come up with a real good set of recommendations moving forward. It was um a group of about 60 people who met every week or every second weekend for like eight hours, really intensive work for six months or so. Um they would get presentations, they would go into breakout rooms, they would get education, like all of this stuff to really understand the issue. And it was really represent— like, this is all from what Knack is saying. It was very representative of the population, and it was really in-depth engagement with this kind of like random randomized sample. So it is, it is different than just “just a survey”.
Mack:
Yeah. Okay. Why did the mayor say we need this? Like, why did, why did he bring this forward in the first place? Like we already have a City Plan. City council can already update it. They already gather input in a variety of ways. Like what's he hoping to accomplish here?
Stephanie:
A lot has changed since 2020 when the City Plan was approved. And also, you know, there was engagement for the City Plan for like five years before that. So it's been about ten years or so since there's been uh like dedicated engagement started on the City Plan. And the report that administration originally wrote said administration proposes to complete a sentiment analysis. So going back and looking at all of the public feedback that they've received over the past uh few years, completing a sentiment analysis, which basically means, like, just summarizing things about what — how — yeah. Yeah.
Mack:
Is it positive or negative? Do more people complain or not? Yeah.
Stephanie:
And then assess the need for any further citywide public engagement on growth to 1.25 million residents. As you can assume, people did not like that. Um, several several groups came out and said, “No, of course we — you should still keep doing engagement.” Like, come on.
Mack:
Okay, so the mayor's I guess trying to avoid further complaints about, hey, you guys didn't engage with us when you decided to make these changes to City Plan. We weren't properly consulted. Little does he know he's gonna hear that feedback regardless of what they do. That is what people are gonna do if they don't like something. But hopefully also we get some useful input and feedback from, from this group of people on this panel. So can anyone join or how how is the panel going to be constructed?
Stephanie:
Uh still TBD. We're not really a hundred percent sure what it's gonna look like. This is just very new from earlier this week. Yeah, I don't know if they'll be putting out uh like applications or just like, do — maybe putting out something through the Edmonton Insight Community. I really have no idea. Mm-hmm.
Mack:
Well, more to come on that. Okay, we said one of the things that City Plan does is helps define where people are gonna live by deciding when parts of the city might become unlocked for development and that sort of thing. So I understand that at Urban Planning Committee there was also discussion about that, and in particular about the substantial completion standard, which has been one of these things that's been talked about over the last number of years as a way to prevent us from just continuing to sprawl. We want to build up the existing areas and make sure they reach a certain level of development before we get, you know, onto new greenfield areas and start to build those out. So what did the committee talk about this week?
Stephanie:
Yeah, so Urban Planning Committee also recommended rescinding a motion that changed the way that the substantial completion standard works. So uh Okay, so let's time travel a little bit back to 2024. This standard took the whole city into account. So even though, for example, Summerside in the south is substantially complete, and this is all based on metrics, um, you know, whether the housing is mostly completed, whether there's like fire stations and stuff like that. So even though Summerside, for example, is substantially complete, Horse Hill up in the north is barely even complete at all. So you can't open up the lands south of Summerside for planning. So and then in 2024, though, council voted to change that a little bit. Instead of doing it in a citywide way, they change it to quadrants. The reasoning there is that the city is sprawling unevenly. The south is kind of bursting at the seams while there's not much demand to live in the north side. And you know, the argument from BILD at the time was that people or BILD Edmonton Metro, the real estate developer advocacy group, their argument was that people are just gonna go to Leduc or Beaumont if they wanna live in the south side, and then Edmonton doesn't have the homes for them, but just gonna go to Leduc or Beaumont because they wanna be down in the south side close to employment centres south of the city, Nisku, Leduc County, the airport. Um, but this week, Urban Planning Committee passed a recommendation that the quadrant rule is rescinded and the city goes back to the citywide requirement.
Mack:
Interesting. Uh I imagine BILD Edmonton is not particularly pleased with this suggested change. Why did this why did this come forward? Who brought forward this idea to go back to the way we were doing it before we had to the quadrants?
Stephanie:
So Michael Janz made the motion. It's linked to the City Plan discussion. Um you can at, you know, at committee meetings, you can kind of make subsequent motions. It's the rules are a little bit looser, so he's able to just like tack on this thing, even though it's not directly related. But he basically said it's because of the infill directive, because if we are as a city being forced to lower the amount of infill that we create. We need to be even more uh intentional about the ways that we sprawl. That's what he says.
Mack:
Okay, that's interesting. I mean, that's one way I suppose to accomplish that. I mean, you could just not approve developments that further the sprawl. It would be another way. Uh I think it also doesn't change the fact that we are sprawling, as you said, in a uh, unequal way. Although I don't know if you've been up in the north side lately, Stephanie, like up Manning and that direction. Like there's a ton of development there too. Like Edmonton is just growing all over the place. Did his motion get support then at committee?
Stephanie:
It's a little bit complicated. Um, so there's only four people on Urban Planning Committee. That's Coun. Anne Stevenson. Currently, it's Coun. Anne Stevenson, Coun. Reed Clarke, Coun. Michael Janz, and Mayor Andrew Knack. Then only committee members vote on these motions. However, this one will still have to be approved by city council. He only got Anne Stevenson to join him, and Andrew Knack was absent. So It was Anne Stevenson and Michael Janz in favour and Reed Clarke opposed. So, like barely had quorum. Um, but again, like I said, yeah.
Mack:
Yeah. But it still goes forward then as a recommendation to the full city council.
Stephanie:
Yeah. But the thing is, is I went back and looked at who voted for the original change to the quadrant rules, and
Mack:
Yes.
Stephanie:
I don't think there's any chance that it changes much because um those were that were in favour were Andrew Knack, Sarah Hamilton, Aaron Paquette, Tim Cartmell, Amarjeet Sohi, Jennifer Rice, Jo-Anne Wright and Karen Principe. Opposed were Ashley Salvador, Michael Janz, Keren Tang, Erin Rutherford and Anne Stevenson. So like I just don't see that many of the re-elected councillors switching sides and I do not see any of the new councillors maybe switching or joining the in favour of the citywide requirement. I don't know. I don't know. We'll see, I guess.
Mack:
Yeah. That that vote you're referencing that was back in July 2024, right? They made that change. So okay, very interesting. Did BILD have any comment in response to this motion? Have we heard from them yet?
Stephanie:
Yeah, so they all were also quite, quite fired up and passionate about this. Lots of saltiness in the city this week. BILD said importantly, this work, so quadrant planning, has continued in the intervening years. The city's discussions, planning activities, and engagements over approximately the past two and a half years have been premised on the adoption of a quadrant-based approach. A decision by council to change course at this stage would represent a significant and abrupt shift in direction, undermining the considerable work undertaken by council, administration, industry, and the community. It would create uncertainty around the assumptions underpinning ongoing growth planning.
Mack:
You know what else creates uncertainty and undermines all the planning work that's been going on? The province dropping out announcements about infill directives and other things from random distances. Like, it just — sure, I understand their point of view on this, but it's not like the city is making this harder than it needs to be, right? If you're gonna point some anger, surely you gotta be pointing it at the province. I don't I don't think Michael Janz is necessarily wrong here. Maybe the approach he's taken by tacking this on to a, a discussion about something else, you could have some questions about that. Maybe there's a more collaborative way to go about doing that. But if our toolbox is now even more limited to help decide how the city's going to grow in the future, we've got to use every tool at our disposal. And maybe this is one of the few tools we still have. Until of course The province comes around and says, No, you can't have substantial completion standards at all.
Stephanie:
No. And of course, this is all coming at a time where BILD is launching a full-fledged campaign to, like, marketing campaign and everything, to get the lands south of 41st Avenue SW opened up. There's a ton of videos, blog posts, social media, et cetera, et cetera. Yeah, they, they really wanna open it up. Um, and it's just like still city council is kind of digging their heels in. One day it will be opened up. And then, and then, and then go crazy, you know.
Mack:
Yeah, I mean the developers obviously would love to not have as many rules and restrictions. They want to be able to continue to, to build out where there's demand. And in a way, we all do as well, right? In that if Edmonton does have a relative housing affordability advantage compared to other cities, we want to maintain that. We want to continue to be an affordable place for people to live. We want to be able to attract people here. Lots of folks up and down the political spectrum would agree with that kind of a statement, right? The challenge is, and has always been, looking into the future, how are we gonna pay for all of that? How are we gonna pay for all the extra thousands of kilometres of roads and pipes and services and everything else? And even if the equations have changed in recent years and that new neighbourhoods are more able to cover costs depending on how you look at the data, it doesn't change the fact that Thousands of kilometres of roads are just more expensive for us to maintain. It's going to necessitate a future tax increase. It's going to make the city more expensive in the long run. So you know you could look at it from that point of view and say, well, city council's really trying to say, let's not just go all in right now and have to deal with this later. Let's try and prevent some of those future problems from coming in by giving ourselves some direction about how this is going to happen in the in the short term. Doesn't help when our ability to do that gets taken away by other levels of government. So again, maybe this is a tool in the toolbox we have. Okay, so we don't know exactly when, but this is going to come back to city council and I'm sure we'll hear more about substantial completion standard, maybe in the context of budget and and maybe a little bit after too. Okay, well, we have one more thing to talk about. As we mentioned off the top, the Grey Cup was a success for Edmonton. We went down to Calgary and the Elks won again against Montreal, 37–30. Did you watch the game, Stephanie? It's all good. Yeah.
Stephanie:
Nope. Sorry. Not a, not a football person. The only football game that I care about is the Super Bowl that Bad Bunny performed at. It was good.
Mack:
That was a good performance. Yeah. I, I did watch the Grey Cup and I didn't watch all of the postgame celebration stuff, but you know, I've been paying attention this week and something keeps coming up. Certain phrase everyone keeps dropping. You know what I'm talking about, Stephanie.
Stephanie:
I do.
Mack:
City of Champions. Whenever Edmonton sports teams, especially the major ones, have any kind of success, it feels like this comes up again. Uh what's your take on City of Champions, Stephanie?
Stephanie:
It's very nostalgic to me. You know, it's it's what I grew up in. And I feel like coming of age in like around 2008, and I would have been 10 in 2008, and then I feel like it really it would have went away in about 2015, which is when I would have been 17, late high school. So, you know, it really — and I'm sorry, I mentioned 2008 because of like the recession and like poor economic times. So I don't know, it really has this spirit of being, like, rugged, blue collar, and the Oilers sucked back then. You know what I mean? Like it's it's to me, the City of Champions is really associated with being underdogs, with being rough, with being blue collar. It reminds me of driving from living in Mill Woods, you know? That is the vibe that City of Champions gives me. And I mean all that in the most positive way. Like I love it. And I do think we should bring City of Champs back. Like it's an awesome slogan.
Mack:
If I've had coffee with you in the last probably six months, you've probably heard me say, I think we need to go all in on City of Champions. If you've been reading what I put out into the world for any length of time, you will know that this is a reversal of the position that I used to hold. So when Make Something Edmonton and these other branding identity exercises were happening, I wrote, you know, that I don't think we should be using City of Champions. And I had a long list of reasons why, you know, including that it's not just about sports. We we're about we need something that's more than just sports. Other cities have called themselves City of Champions over the years, you know, all these kinds of things. I've changed my mind, Stephanie. I think one of the reasons that initiatives like Make Something Edmonton never really took off is that there was nothing for — I don't mean this in a negative way — just nothing for the average Edmontonian to latch on to, right? Whereas I think you could go to almost any random Edmontonian on the street and ask them if they heard of City of Champions or if they identified with that, and they'd have some sort of a reaction like you did, right? Which is there'd be some positive connection to it, right? So I've been telling people for months now that I think what we need to do is just say we're City of Champions, adopt it whole hog, and then scaffold on top of it. So now we've got everyday regular Edmontonians walking around talking about how we're the City of Champions, branding campaigns and other things we might want to do, we can define what a champion is. Entrepreneur can be a champion, right? Somebody who works in the health-care sector serving our community can be a champion. It doesn't just have to be about sports, right? The history of City of Champions, right, goes all the way back to the Edmonton Grads. It was closely associated with the Oilers and the, and the Eskimos at the time in, uh, in the '80s. The tornado as well was another thing, that volunteerism, like there's been various things over the years, which proves already that City of Champions can be broader than just one thing, right? And so I think if we go all in on that, that would be a positive thing to get people talking about it. Because remember, the branding exercise to me is first and foremost about Edmontonians. Nobody's gonna move to Edmonton because we're the City of Champions, just like nobody's moving to Calgary because they're Blue Sky City. What they would move to Edmonton for is if they saw that the people in Edmonton are so proud of their city and talk about it so positively that they're like, that's a place that I want to be. There's opportunity there, housing's affordable. Those people seem to love where they live. I want to move there. So City of Champions, the brand, and all of that is really for the people that are already here to have positive things to say about this place. The other thing, Stephanie, that I think would make a big difference here is anytime branding identity stuff comes up at City Council. What do people say? What a waste of money. Don't waste our tax dollars on that. This gives you a win. City Council can just say, hey, you know what? We didn't commission a multimillion-dollar new, you know, brand exercise. We just adopted City of Champions. You know, we're going to take the old signs out of storage. We're going to put them back. That's how much money we're saving you with the City of Champions thing. You were at an event this week and they had a City of Champions sign on stage, right?
Stephanie:
Yeah, I I was. And it's funny that you mention the different definitions of champions. So I was at the Edmonton Chamber of Commerce State of the Economy report, which uh basically just talks about job growth and industry growth in the region. But they had this sign up on stage, and one of the speakers that was talking was um Andrew McIsaac, who is the CEO of Applied Pharmaceutical Innovation, which is like this company that supports pharmaceutical innovation that kind of comes out of the post-secondaries and it helps researchers commercialize their innovations. He said that champions — City of Champions — can mean someone that champions the city, you know, it, like, being a champion for the tech community for health innovation, being a champion for the art scene, being a champion for Yeah, the the environment, all these different things.
Mack:
Absolutely. Yeah. So you had another bit of evidence in support of this proposal, right? It also got a little bit of attention at City Council this week. Coun. Reed Clarke, who you mentioned earlier, gave notice of motion that he would like to have city staff explore how City of Champions could be used and how it could fit into the existing brand work. So just as a, a little bit of a, a refresher, back in January this year, executive committee approved a motion to implement what is called the 2026–2029 Edmonton Place Brand Framework. And there's been some stuff in the, in the interim that's happened. It's gone out to tender. You know, there's been a an organization, a group of people here, I was consulted on this along with a bunch of others who've been thinking about the governance of what this should look like. By the way, my idea for that is we should create like a commissioner's office for brand that's separate from council and administration, kind of, kind of like this — the office of the city auditor. It's like the office of the city brand and they wouldn't police it, but they would make sure everybody knows about it, make sure all the organizations are aligned. Anyway, we can talk more about that when governance comes back to council. This place brand framework is moving forward though, and there is some stuff in the budget, including uh $1.19 million and two full-time positions in 2027 for what the city calls its brand and reputation unit. And so they would produce assets and track how people perceive the city and do all of the work to try to, you know, move that forward. It's not a huge budget, two people for such a big project, but it's a it's a start. And then when we do talk about City of Champions on the entrance signs, that's actually in the capital budget too, as an unfunded profile. $400,000, I believe it is. It's not a super high priority. Like if you look at the budget as you know, there's a bunch of Priorities and it's number 32 on the list. So there's lots of other things that administration feels like probably are more important than doing this. But maybe because of the Elks' success here with the Grey Cup, we're gonna see more attention on that during this budget cycle. Maybe it'll move up the list in terms of uh in terms of priorities. So okay, that's what I wanted to say. I think City of Champions, I've come around to it again. I think that's what we should do, Stephanie. Not just because of the Elks, but just more broadly, I think that is the sort of foundation that we can build upon to, you know, really take the place brand forward, right? City brand being city of Edmonton, place brand being what is Edmonton and who are we all about, I think you can connect it with the risk taking and stuff that we've talked about in recent years, some of which is really, really good. But City of Champions is that short, simple thing that everybody can can kind of latch on to.
Stephanie:
I love it. Just put them signs back up. You know what I mean? Like like
Mack:
Put the signs back up.
Stephanie:
It doesn't have to be an exercise. I'll tell you right now, city employees, just put the signs back up. People will love it. In summary. Yeah.
Mack:
People already do, right? On this — on Monday, I think somebody went and put up a sign on Gateway Boulevard, uh, after the, after the Grey Cup weekend, right? So
Stephanie:
Yeah.
Mack:
Uh okay, one more thing on this. I did consult Taproot's archives because we've been writing about brand and all this kind of stuff for years. And we actually had “A Moment in History,” which is one of our recurring features, from a number of years ago. And it was looking back in 1928 when we were arguing about the slogan for the city all the way back then. “All Together for Edmonton” was picked from about 14,000 suggestions. There was a bunch of other ones. But interestingly, the only official slogan we've ever had, the only one that's actually been sanctioned by the city of Edmonton was in 1947. We were the Oil Capital of Canada. Can you believe that?
Stephanie:
And that's so funny because like the, like, oil wasn't even really discovered in Edmonton. It was in Leduc, wasn't it?
Mack:
Yeah.
Stephanie:
We're more like the oil — we're, and we're not even the refinery capital because those aren't even in — we don't even have the industrial land. Some of them are.
Mack:
Yeah, some of them are in Edmonton. But you know what? It's a — it was regional thinking all the way back in 1947. Yeah.
Stephanie:
Aww.
Mack:
I'll put the link for that in the show notes as well. You can go read a little bit more about the history of uh branding in Edmonton. And then we'll keep you posted in the next couple of weeks here with budget and whether or not they decide to fund putting the signs back up on the welcome signs around the city. All right, rant over on City of Champions. Uh there was a lot of other stuff we didn't even get to this week. We're gonna talk more about like, last week we talked about Buffalo Crossing LRT. I think committee recommended that to council. That's going to council. We've got follow-ups on the ETS merch shop. We all now have the
Stephanie:
And budget starts next week.
Mack:
The Transit Royale app and budgets going. That's right. So lots more to get into in the weeks ahead. We hope you'll join us next week again for another episode. And until then, I'm Mack.
Stephanie:
I'm Stephanie.
Mack:
And we're...
Both:
Speaking Municipally.
Creators and Guests
